The Most Important Question Ever Asked - February 2018

From Tar Valon Library
Jump to: navigation, search

Author: Kyla Sterling, February 2018


2017-12 TVT Banner 15.png


Oscar season is upon us, and Mr. Sterling has been busily watching all the Best Picture nominees so he can get his reviews and podcast out before the big night. And me? I've watched a couple this year, but I'm not terribly excited about their chances of winning.

Buuuuuuut it did get me thinking about a certain past winner: GIF

And its controversial ending:

2018-02 Question 1.jpeg


Explored at length in several ways and places.

2018-02 Question 2.jpg


Even by the Mythbusters! (Though they only ruled it "plausible" that they both could have survived, and not a certainty...)

2018-02 Question 3.jpg


So, Tar Valon - what's the deal with Jack and Rose??


Results
Options Votes Percentage of votes
Absolutely, there was room for two! 1 16.7%
Absolutely not, their combined weight would have been too much to keep them out of the water! 1 16.7%
Maybe, if they could counteract the buoyancy issue... 1 16.7%
Maybe not, because they wouldn't have been able to flag down the lifeboat... 0 0.0%
Are we STILL talking about this?? 3 50.0%